Facial care routine at the sink, natural light

Facial toner: A useful step or a practice left over from a bygone era?

Is a toner really necessary after cleansing? Where does this step come from, what do we know about the skin’s pH, and why does a gentle cleanser often make this step unnecessary?

By Dr. Anais Bambili 5-minute read

For a long time, we were taught that a clean face had to be “sealed” with a toner: a cotton pad soaked in toner, a refreshing sensation, and the feeling that the job was done. Yet this reassuring ritual is based on a way of thinking from a bygone era. Facial toner was created to repair the damage that old-fashioned soaps used to inflict on the skin. With a gentle cleanser, there’s often nothing left to repair—and this extra step can even strip away what we were trying to protect.

Where Does Toner Really Come From?

To understand this bottle, we need to go back to our grandparents’ bathrooms. People used to wash there with very alkaline soaps and water that was often hard. Together, they left a thin film of residue on the face—the same kind of buildup found at the bottom of sinks. Toner, which usually contained alcohol, was used to remove this film and soothe the irritation it caused.

American dermatologist Zoe Draelos, who has written extensively on cosmetic formulation, sums it up simply: the original purpose of toner has largely disappeared along with those soaps, but the product itself has remained a part of skincare routines. She also points out that it is not necessary for skin health.

The Skin's pH: What We're Really Trying to Preserve

The most common argument in favor of toner is that it “restores pH balance.” This premise is correct. The skin’s surface is naturally slightly acidic, and this acidity is no trivial matter: it helps organize the lipid cement of the stratum corneum, ensures the proper shedding of dead cells, and maintains the balance of the skin’s microbiome.

A multicenter study published in 2006 inthe *International Journal of Cosmetic Science* measured this pH level in volunteers after a day without showering or using any products. The authors concluded that skin, when left to its own devices, is more acidic than previously thought, and that the most acidic skin had a stronger barrier, better hydration, and fewer flakes. They also observed that soaps—and even plain tap water—raise this pH level for several hours before the skin naturally returns to its acidic state. This is one of the effects we discuss in detail in our article onhard water.

In other words, the skin knows how to restore its balance. The important thing is not to disturb it unnecessarily twice a day.

How the cleaner made a difference

So the real question isn't "Should you moisturize after cleansing?" but "Why cleanse in a way that requires moisturizing?" A study published in *Dermatologic Therapy* showed that harsh surfactants damage the proteins and lipids in the stratum corneum, resulting in that tight feeling on the skin after rinsing, dryness, and sometimes itching. The authors point out that the cleanser’s pH can exacerbate these effects, and that a formula with a pH close to that of the skin is less likely to cause damage.

That’s where it all comes down to. A gentle cleanser leaves no residue to remove and no acidity to restore. VIBRE PARIS’s Gentle Cleansing Gel was designed with this in mind: to remove sebum, sweat, and whatever else the day has left behind, without stripping away the skin’s protective lipids. After rinsing, the skin remains supple. There’s nothing left to fix.

VIBRE PARIS Gentle Cleansing Gel in natural light

Gentle Cleansing Gel — VIBRE PARIS

When a step is meant to correct the previous one, it is the previous one that needs to be changed.

When Tonic Becomes a Problem

Many toners still contain alcohol or astringents. The cooling sensation they provide is pleasant, but it often leads to dryness: the skin appears “clean” because it has lost some of its protective barrier.

The American Academy of Dermatology is clear on this point for acne-prone skin: it recommends gentle, alcohol-free skincare products and advises avoiding astringents, toners, and exfoliants, which can dry out the skin and make breakouts more visible. Toners containing exfoliating acids pose another challenge: they add to the other active ingredients in your skincare routine, and it’s often this accumulation—rather than any single product on its own—that ends up causing irritation. If your skin feels tight after using a cotton pad, our article on tight skin after cleansing can help you understand the causes.

Three steps, with no intermediate steps

Newer toners promise something else: to hydrate and “prepare” the skin for the next steps. This role already exists in a well-structured skincare routine. Applied immediately after cleansing, on skin that’s still slightly damp, the Regenerating Serum delivers niacinamide, which supports the skin barrier and refines skin texture. Next, the Plumping Cream seals in the benefits with its multi-ceramides, which are similar to the lipids the skin produces on its own.

VIBRE PARIS Regenerating Serum with Niacinamide Bottle

Regenerating Serum — VIBRE PARIS

Clean without stripping, treat, and protect the skin barrier: that’s the whole concept behind La Routine—the same three steps every morning and evening. No cotton pads, no steps to correct the previous one.

"La Routine VIBRE PARIS" Gift Set featuring a cleansing gel, serum, and cream

The Routine — VIBRE PARIS

If you like your toner and your skin tolerates it, there’s no reason you have to stop using it. But if you’re only using it out of habit, you can let it go without any regrets. Your skin doesn’t need to be “sealed.” It just needs to be treated gently.

Sources

  • Lambers H, Piessens S, Bloem A, Pronk H, Finkel P. “Natural skin surface pH is, on average, below 5, which is beneficial for its resident flora.” International Journal of Cosmetic Science, 2006 — PubMed
  • Ananthapadmanabhan KP, Moore DJ, Subramanyan K et al. “Cleansing without compromise: the impact of cleansers on the skin barrier and the technology of mild cleansing.” Dermatologic Therapy, 2004 — PubMed
  • Draelos ZD. “Are facial toners necessary?” Dermatology Times — dermatologytimes.com
  • American Academy of Dermatology — “Acne: Tips for Managing” (aad.org)

3 minutes

blemishes, wrinkles, redness. A routine.

Discover the 3 treatments · 30% off

Cleanser · Serum · Cream — ★★★★★ 4.8/5 · over 200 reviews