Dark circles, under-eye bags, and drooping eyelids: is a facelift an effective solution?

The eyes are often described as the mirror of the soul. However, they are also one of the first areas of the face to reveal signs of fatigue and aging. Prominent dark circles, persistent under-eye bags, heavy or drooping eyelids: these changes alter expression and can sometimes give a sad or tired appearance, even when a person is well-rested. Faced with these issues, aesthetic solutions are multiplying, ranging from cosmetic treatments to injections, and even surgery. Among these, eyelid surgery – or blepharoplasty – is often presented as the go-to procedure. But is this operation truly effective against dark circles, under-eye bags, and drooping eyelids?

1. Understanding common eye area concerns

Dark Circles

Dark circles appear as shadows or discolorations under the eyes. These include:

  • Bluish or purplish dark circles: linked to fragile blood microcirculation and thin skin.

  • Brown dark circles: due to local hyperpigmentation.

  • Hollow dark circles: linked to a loss of volume in the tear trough, which accentuates the shadow.

Under-eye bags

They correspond to a protrusion of orbital fat or water retention. They give a puffy and tired appearance. With age, the skin loses its elasticity and supporting tissues weaken, which increases their visibility.

Drooping eyelids

Ptosis or dermatochalasis manifests as excess skin on the upper eyelid. It can make the eyes look heavy, hinder makeup application, and in some severe cases, affect vision.

2. Main Causes

  • Natural aging: loss of skin elasticity, muscle relaxation, and fat reabsorption.

  • Genetic factors: predisposition to fatty pockets or hyperpigmentation.

  • Lifestyle: lack of sleep, tobacco, alcohol, stress, unbalanced diet.

  • Environment: sun exposure, pollution, blue light.

3. Non-Surgical Solutions

Before considering surgery, many alternatives exist:

  • Specific cosmetics (dark circle creams, caffeine serums, retinol, vitamin C).

  • Hyaluronic acid injections to fill hollow dark circles.

  • Botulinum toxin to smooth certain wrinkles around the eyes.

  • Laser, radiofrequency, focused ultrasound to stimulate collagen production and tighten the skin.

  • Chemical peels to reduce pigmented dark circles.

These techniques often offer temporary and gradual improvement, but they do not always effectively treat excess skin or a pronounced fatty hernia.

4. Eyelid Lift (Blepharoplasty)

What does the operation involve?

Blepharoplasty is a cosmetic surgery designed to correct excess skin and/or fat pockets around the eyelids. It is divided into:

  • Upper Blepharoplasty: involves removing excess skin and sometimes muscle from the upper eyelid.

  • Lower Blepharoplasty: addresses fat pockets and sagging skin under the eyes.

The procedure is performed under local or light general anesthesia, lasts between 30 minutes and 2 hours, and the scars are usually inconspicuous, hidden within natural skin folds.

5. Effectiveness of the Procedure on Dark Circles, Under-Eye Bags, and Eyelids

  • For under-eye bags: the procedure is considered the most effective solution, as it allows for the permanent removal or repositioning of excess fat.

  • For drooping eyelids: removing excess skin creates a more open and rejuvenated look, with dramatic and lasting results.

  • For dark circles: its effectiveness is more limited. The procedure mainly corrects hollow dark circles caused by fat bulges or sagging skin, but it is ineffective for pigmented or vascular dark circles.

In summary, blepharoplasty is very effective for under-eye bags and drooping eyelids, but only partially effective for dark circles.

6. Expected Results

The most common benefits include:

  • A more open, rested, and rejuvenated appearance.

  • Disappearance of unsightly under-eye bags.

  • Reduction of hollow dark circles caused by shadows.

  • Improved facial symmetry.

Results appear gradually over the weeks following the operation and are long-lasting, typically 8 to 10 years, sometimes even longer.

7. Risks and Limitations

Like any surgical procedure, blepharoplasty carries certain risks:

  • Hematomas, edema, temporary bruising.

  • Dry eyes or excessive tearing.

  • Rare hypertrophic scars.

  • An unflattering outcome if too much skin is removed ('hollow eye').

  • Asymmetry or partial persistence of dark circles.

Careful selection of candidates, an experienced surgeon, and a precise assessment of expectations are essential to minimize these risks.

8. Complementary Alternatives to the Procedure

In some cases, the procedure alone is not enough. It can be combined with:

  • Hyaluronic acid injections to soften residual dark circles.

  • Peeling or fractional laser to even out skin color and texture.

  • Temporal or frontal lift if the sagging extends to the eyebrows.

This combined approach offers a more comprehensive and personalized treatment for the eye contour area.

Eyelid lift (blepharoplasty) is the most effective surgical procedure for treating under-eye bags and drooping eyelids. Its results are clear, long-lasting, and generally very satisfying. However, its effectiveness is limited for certain types of dark circles, particularly pigmented or vascular ones, which require other complementary approaches.

Therefore, a facelift is not a universal solution, but it represents an excellent option for individuals experiencing skin sagging or prominent under-eye bags. A personalized consultation with a qualified aesthetic surgeon allows for evaluating the suitability of this procedure based on individual morphology, expectations, and the nature of the dark circles.

Ultimately, surgery can restore radiance and youthfulness to the eyes, provided one fully understands its indications, benefits, and limitations.

Back to blog